Safety scores and transparency grades from federal incident data · 2021-22 collection
Typical home value: $340,803 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026-06-30) — cheaper than 38% of ZHVI-matched cities. Comparing safety against price? See the Affordable & Safe guide.
| SCHOOL | DISTRICT | GRADES | STUDENTS | SAFETY SCORE | GRADE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Highville Charter School | Highville Charter School District | PK–12 | 499 | 91 | A |
| Elm City Montessori School | Elm City Montessori School District | PK–07 | 282 | 69 | A |
| Fair Haven School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 731 | 68 | A |
| Mauro-Sheridan Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 474 | 65 | A |
| John S. Martinez Sea and Sky STEM School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 448 | 65 | A |
| Davis Academy for Arts & Design Innovation | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 435 | 65 | A |
| Beecher School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 429 | 64 | A |
| Barnard Environmental Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 409 | 64 | A |
| Family Academy of Multilingual Exploration | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 403 | 64 | A |
| Worthington Hooker School | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 393 | 64 | A |
| Brennan Rogers School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 378 | 64 | A |
| Betsy Ross Arts Magnet School | New Haven School District | 05–08 | 347 | 63 | A |
| Wexler/Grant Community School | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 318 | 62 | A |
| Barack H. Obama Magnet University School | New Haven School District | PK–04 | 287 | 62 | A |
| Hill Regional Career High School | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 634 | 61 | A |
| Cooperative High School - Inter-District Magnet | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 573 | 60 | A |
| East Rock Community Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 448 | 60 | A |
| John C. Daniels | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 413 | 60 | A |
| Nathan Hale School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 514 | 60 | A |
| Roberto Clemente Leadership Academy for Global Awareness | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 400 | 59 | A |
| Sound School | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 339 | 58 | A |
| Clinton Avenue School | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 474 | 55 | A |
| Lincoln-Bassett School | New Haven School District | PK–06 | 270 | 54 | A |
| High School In The Community | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 267 | 54 | A |
| Truman School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 461 | 53 | A |
| Benjamin Jepson Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 428 | 52 | A |
| Conte/West Hills Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 581 | 51 | A |
| Ross/Woodward School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 579 | 48 | A |
| Hill Central Music Academy | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 418 | 48 | A |
| Metropolitan Business Academy | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 390 | 43 | A |
| King/Robinson Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 408 | 41 | A |
| New Haven Academy | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 330 | 41 | A |
| Augusta Lewis Troup School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 413 | 40 | A |
| Edgewood School | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 408 | 36 | A |
| Wilbur Cross High School | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 1,577 | 36 | A |
| James Hillhouse High School | New Haven School District | 09–12 | 1,180 | 34 | A |
| Common Ground High School | Common Ground High School District | 09–12 | 231 | 32 | A |
| Celentano BioTech Health and Medical Magnet School | New Haven School District | PK–08 | 342 | 31 | A |
| Bishop Woods Architecture and Design Magnet School | New Haven School District | KG–08 | 451 | 26 | A |
| Elm City College Preparatory School | Elm City College Preparatory School District | KG–12 | 578 | 25 | A |
| Amistad Academy | Amistad Academy District | KG–12 | 1,581 | 18 | A |
| Booker T. Washington Academy | Booker T. Washington Academy District | KG–08 | 519 | 11 | A |
| Quinnipiac Real World Math STEM School | New Haven School District | M–M | — insufficient data | ||
| West Rock Authors Academy | New Haven School District | M–M | — insufficient data |