| NORTH BAY HAVEN CAREER ACADEMY | BAY | 09–12 | 906 | 48 | A |
| PARKER ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 679 | 47 | A |
| CALLAWAY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 440 | 41 | A |
| PALM BAY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | KG–05 | 281 | 40 | A |
| RISING LEADERS ACADEMY | BAY | KG–12 | 279 | 40 | A |
| NORTHSIDE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 581 | 40 | A |
| CEDAR GROVE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 524 | 39 | A |
| BAY HAVEN CHARTER MIDDLE SCHOOL | BAY | 06–08 | 438 | 38 | A |
| BAY VIRTUAL INSTRUCTION PROGRAM (DISTRICT PROVIDED) | BAY | KG–12 | 171 | 36 | A |
| MARGARET K. LEWIS IN MILLVILLE | BAY | PK–12 | 155 | 35 | A |
| MERRIAM CHERRY STREET ELEMENTARY | BAY | PK–05 | 453 | 35 | A |
| BAY VIRTUAL FRANCHISE | BAY | KG–12 | 139 | 35 | A |
| PALM BAY PREPARATORY ACADEMY 6-12 | BAY | 06–12 | 207 | 34 | A |
| ST. ANDREW SCHOOL AT OAKLAND TERRACE | BAY | PK–05 | 108 | 33 | A |
| CENTRAL HIGH SCHOOL | BAY | 09–12 | 89 | 32 | A |
| CHAUTAUQUA CHARTER SCHOOL | BAY | 09–12 | 47 | 30 | A |
| LUCILLE MOORE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 437 | 30 | A |
| NORTH BAY HAVEN CHARTER ACADEMY MIDDLE SCHOOL | BAY | 06–08 | 526 | 28 | A |
| DEANE BOZEMAN SCHOOL | BAY | PK–12 | 1,467 | 19 | A |
| BAY HIGH SCHOOL | BAY | 09–12 | 1,112 | 15 | A |
| MERRITT BROWN MIDDLE SCHOOL | BAY | 06–08 | 677 | 13 | A |
| NEW HORIZONS LEARNING CENTER | BAY | 06–12 | 112 | 10 | A |
| JINKS MIDDLE SCHOOL | BAY | 06–08 | 504 | 10 | A |
| ROSENWALD HIGH SCHOOL | BAY | 06–12 | 244 | 9 | A |
| RUTHERFORD HIGH SCHOOL | BAY | 06–12 | 1,393 | 8 | A |
| AMIKIDS MARITIME ACADEMY | BAY | M–M | | — insufficient data | |
| BAY HAVEN CHARTER ACADEMY | BAY | KG–05 | 786 | — insufficient data | F |
| BAY REGIONAL JUVENILE DETENTION CENTER | BAY | KG–12 | 24 | — insufficient data | A |
| BAY VIRTUAL INSTRUCTION PROGRAM | BAY | KG–12 | 11 | — insufficient data | A |
| CENTRAL ACADEMY | BAY | 06–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| DEER POINT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 566 | — insufficient data | F |
| EXCEPTIONAL STUDENT EDUCATION | BAY | PK–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| HILAND PARK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 541 | — insufficient data | F |
| HUTCHISON BEACH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 656 | — insufficient data | F |
| NORTH BAY HAVEN CHARTER ACADEMY ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | KG–05 | 697 | — insufficient data | F |
| TOMMY SMITH ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY | PK–05 | 515 | — insufficient data | F |
| UNIVERSITY ACADEMY SABL INC | BAY | KG–08 | 679 | — insufficient data | F |