Safety scores and transparency grades from federal incident data · 2021-22 collection
Typical home value: $663,767 (Zillow ZHVI, 2026-06-30) — cheaper than 9% of ZHVI-matched cities. Comparing safety against price? See the Affordable & Safe guide.
| SCHOOL | DISTRICT | GRADES | STUDENTS | SAFETY SCORE | GRADE |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| BAY SHORE MIDDLE SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | 06–08 | 1,329 | 91 | A |
| BAY SHORE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | 09–12 | 1,919 | 91 | A |
| BROOK AVENUE ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–02 | 371 | 91 | A |
| FIFTH AVENUE SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–02 | 388 | 91 | A |
| GARDINER MANOR SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | 03–05 | 637 | 91 | A |
| MARY G CLARKSON SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–02 | 438 | 91 | A |
| SOUTH COUNTRY SCHOOL | BAY SHORE UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | 03–05 | 487 | 91 | A |
| WOODHULL SCHOOL | FIRE ISLAND UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | PK–06 | 36 | 91 | A |
| HEMLOCK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–05 | 608 | 68 | A |
| SOUTHWEST ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–05 | 969 | 46 | A |
| OAK PARK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | BRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | KG–05 | 722 | — insufficient data | F |
| WEST MIDDLE SCHOOL | BRENTWOOD UNION FREE SCHOOL DISTRICT | 06–08 | 860 | — insufficient data | F |