| Buckhorn High School | 09–12 | 1,285 | 99 | A |
| New Market School | PK–06 | 355 | 92 | A |
| Harvest School | PK–05 | 645 | 77 | A |
| Mt Carmel Elementary School | PK–03 | 590 | 56 | A |
| New Hope Elementary School | PK–06 | 533 | 55 | A |
| Central School | PK–08 | 629 | 54 | A |
| Moores Mill Intermediate School | 04–06 | 731 | 53 | A |
| Hazel Green Elementary School | PK–04 | 676 | 53 | A |
| Sparkman High School | 10–12 | 1,743 | 52 | A |
| Monrovia Elementary School | PK–05 | 476 | 50 | A |
| Riverton Intermediate School | 04–06 | 758 | 41 | A |
| Monrovia Middle School | 06–08 | 959 | 32 | A |
| Madison County High School | 09–12 | 491 | 28 | A |
| New Hope High School | 07–12 | 576 | 24 | A |
| Sparkman Ninth Grade School | 09–09 | 659 | 23 | A |
| Buckhorn Middle School | 07–08 | 666 | 22 | A |
| Meridianville Middle School | 07–08 | 683 | 20 | A |
| Endeavor Elementary School | PK–05 | 590 | 6 | A |
| Hazel Green High School | 09–12 | 1,279 | — insufficient data | E |
| Legacy Elementary School | PK–05 | 612 | — insufficient data | C |
| Lynn Fanning Elementary School | PK–03 | 624 | — insufficient data | C |
| Madison County Alternative School | 01–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| Madison County Career Technical Center | 09–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| Madison County Elementary School | PK–08 | 364 | — insufficient data | D |
| Madison County Virtual Academy | 04–12 | 625 | — insufficient data | D |
| Madison Cross Roads Elementary School | PK–05 | 844 | — insufficient data | C |
| Owens Cross Roads School | PK–04 | 278 | — insufficient data | C |
| Riverton Elementary School | PK–03 | 510 | — insufficient data | C |
| Sparkman Middle School | 06–08 | 962 | — insufficient data | E |
| Walnut Grove School | PK–06 | 249 | — insufficient data | C |