| JULINGTON CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 908 | 100 | A |
| PONTE VEDRA PALM VALLEY- RAWLINGS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 1,044 | 99 | A |
| SOUTH WOODS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 577 | 99 | A |
| TIMBERLIN CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 1,119 | 98 | A |
| PALENCIA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 848 | 91 | A |
| HICKORY CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 881 | 88 | A |
| FREEDOM CROSSING ACADEMY | PK–08 | 2,184 | 88 | A |
| LIBERTY PINES ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,423 | 84 | A |
| THE WEBSTER SCHOOL | PK–05 | 437 | 84 | A |
| VALLEY RIDGE ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,266 | 83 | A |
| R J MURRAY MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 644 | 78 | A |
| MILL CREEK ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,754 | 74 | A |
| CUNNINGHAM CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 555 | 70 | A |
| KETTERLINUS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 407 | 69 | A |
| ALICE B. LANDRUM MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 1,207 | 64 | A |
| TOCOI CREEK HIGH SCHOOL | 09–12 | 1,306 | 57 | A |
| OTIS A. MASON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 671 | 55 | A |
| PONTE VEDRA HIGH SCHOOL | 09–12 | 1,889 | 51 | A |
| SWITZERLAND POINT MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 1,296 | 44 | A |
| ALLEN D NEASE SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL | 09–12 | 2,569 | 37 | A |
| ST. JOHNS TECHNICAL HIGH SCHOOL | 06–12 | 257 | 35 | A |
| BARTRAM TRAIL HIGH SCHOOL | 09–12 | 3,215 | 28 | A |
| SEBASTIAN MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 702 | 24 | A |
| FRUIT COVE MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 1,195 | 22 | A |
| CREEKSIDE HIGH SCHOOL | 09–12 | 2,459 | 21 | A |
| PACETTI BAY MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 1,362 | 18 | A |
| GAMBLE ROGERS MIDDLE SCHOOL | 06–08 | 917 | 12 | A |
| ST. AUGUSTINE HIGH SCHOOL | 08–12 | 1,794 | 10 | A |
| PEDRO MENENDEZ HIGH SCHOOL | 08–12 | 1,482 | 8 | A |
| GAINES ALTERNATIVE AT HAMBLEN | 05–12 | 56 | 6 | A |
| ST JOHNS COUNTY TRANSITION PROGRAM | KG–12 | 46 | 1 | A |
| CROOKSHANK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 611 | — insufficient data | C |
| DEEP CREEK YOUTH ACADEMY | 06–12 | 36 | — insufficient data | C |
| DURBIN CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 864 | — insufficient data | C |
| FIRST COAST TECHNICAL COLLEGE | 09–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| HASTINGS JUVENILE CORRECTIONAL | M–M | | — insufficient data | |
| HIGH SCHOOL III | M–M | | — insufficient data | |
| LIFE WORK/PROJECT SEARCH | 12–12 | 41 | — insufficient data | C |
| MKY- HEAD START /DPP PK SCHOOL | PK–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| OCEAN PALMS ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 824 | — insufficient data | C |
| OSCEOLA ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 580 | — insufficient data | C |
| PALM VALLEY ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,559 | — insufficient data | E |
| PATRIOT OAKS ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,250 | — insufficient data | E |
| PICOLATA CROSSING ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 866 | — insufficient data | C |
| PINE ISLAND ACADEMY | PK–08 | 1,111 | — insufficient data | E |
| R. B. HUNT ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 582 | — insufficient data | C |
| ST JOHNS COUNTY JUVENILE RESIDENTIAL | 06–12 | 49 | — insufficient data | C |
| ST. AUGUSTINE PUBLIC MONTESSORI SCHOOL (SAPMS) | KG–06 | 113 | — insufficient data | C |
| ST. JOHNS COMMUNITY CAMPUS | 09–12 | 40 | — insufficient data | C |
| ST. JOHNS COUNTY JAIL (DJJ) | 09–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| ST. JOHNS VIRTUAL FRANCHISE | KG–12 | 918 | — insufficient data | E |
| ST. JOHNS VIRTUAL INSTRUCTION PROGRAM K-8 | KG–10 | 1 | — insufficient data | C |
| ST. JOHNS VIRTUAL INSTRUCTIONAL PROGRAM | KG–12 | | — insufficient data | |
| THERAPEUTIC LEARNING CENTER | PK–PK | | — insufficient data | C |
| W. DOUGLAS HARTLEY ELEMENTARY | PK–05 | 625 | — insufficient data | C |
| WARDS CREEK ELEMENTARY SCHOOL | PK–05 | 750 | — insufficient data | C |